Time to Be Downbeat About Wal-Mart?

When I bought Wal-Mart (WMT) a bit more than a year ago, I wrote an article for Financial Times where I laid out my theses.

Time to Be Downbeat About Wal-Mart

When I bought Wal-Mart (WMT) a bit more than a year ago, I wrote an article for Financial Times where I laid out my theses:

Wal-Mart currently appeals mostly to lower income demographics, and this is where things will change the most… Cleaner, better, more appropriately merchandised stores will attract new customers… encourage shoppers to… spend more… As initiatives take effect and the shopping experience improves, Wal-Mart will be taking market share from upper scale retailers…

I was wrong! Wal-Mart failed to improve its stores and merchandising to attract a more affluent shopper (the sub-par same store sales are a testament to that). Thus future fundamental return (earnings growth and dividends) will likely be in the high single digits, below original estimates, making the stock fairly valued (at best) at today’s valuation. My (accounting) loss on the purchase was miniscule – because I did not overpay for the stock; however, I experienced an opportunity cost loss as the market has appreciated since.

Please read the following important disclosure here.

Enjoyed this read?

Share it with someone who’d love it too!

New to investing?

Explore these valuable guides to get started.

Value Investing
Student
Curriculum

The 6
Commandments
of Value
Investing

Letter to
a Young
Investor

Related Articles

Current thoughts on Tesla (TSLA)

Current thoughts on Tesla

Tesla market value of $780 billion mostly reflects Elon's future dreams, not car sales. The reality? Only $100-180 billion tied to the actual vehicle business.
Europe Can’t Hide Behind America Anymore

Europe Can’t Hide Behind America Anymore

Americans have always outspent Europe on defense, but to be fair, we have a currency advantage. Our military might elevated our currency to reserve status.
Europe’s New Status: The Children’s Table (IMA Client Dinner 2025 Video)

IMA’s March 2025 Client Dinner Video

Once a year, my company, IMA, hosts a dinner for our clients. Most of them live outside of Denver—and many outside the U.S.—so this event gives us a rare and meaningful chance to meet face-to-face, often for the first time, and really get to know each other.
The Reputational Bankruptcy of the American Dollar

The Reputational Bankruptcy of the American Dollar

The US dollar will likely continue to get weaker, which is inflationary for the US. Let me start with some easily identifiable reasons.

Leave a Comment