Oil, Commodities, AI, and Cyclicality – Ep 308

Share:

Trillions of dollars are being spent on the supply side, while the demand side is uncertain. This is what would keep me up at night if I owned these stocks.

This year, $2.2 trillion will go to renewables, grids, and other clean energy, and less than $500 billion to oil supply. Oil investment is falling for the third year in a row. Meanwhile, the industry now reinvests only about half of its operating cash flow and returns most of the rest to shareholders. Output from the big oil companies is expected to stay flat or grow in the low single digits through the end of the decade.

In this excerpt from my Fall 2026 IMA client letter, I work through how I got semi-comfortable owning oil stocks by marrying two mental models: capital cycles (via Marathon Asset Management and Edward Chancellor’s Capital Account) and Nassim Taleb’s antifragility. Supply is easier to count than demand. Cycles happen because each company’s rational decision adds up to industry-level irrationality. Even OPEC can’t hold the line.

Then a detour I had to get off my fingers: the AI capital cycle. Google, Meta, Amazon, Microsoft, Apple, joined by SpaceX, OpenAI, and Anthropic, each treating AI as existential, each investing as if its life depends on it. FOMO replaced by FOBI. I walk through why these businesses are becoming more capital intensive, why balance sheets have flipped from net cash to indebted, and Paul Kedrosky’s point that 70% of AI usage today comes from 1% of users (mostly software engineers burning tokens by the truckload).

Back to oil: Brent at $90, the Iran war, Ukraine destroying Russian oil infrastructure, and why I think the companies we own are antifragile. I also talk about the bottle of beer that ends the binge.

Read the full letter at investor.fm.

_________________________________________________________ 🔗 LINKS MENTIONED: The Church of Climate and the Law of Unintended Consequences https://investor.fm/the-church-of-climate-and-the-law-of-unintended-consequences

Skin in the Game, Steam in the Ground https://investor.fm/skin-in-the-game-steam-in-the-ground-part-3/

Why We Bought Aker BP: A Technology First Oil Company https://investor.fm/why-we-bought-aker-bp-a-technology-first-oil-company-part-4/

_________________________________________________________ 📩 Join 100,000+ readers on Vitaliy’s FREE weekly newsletter: https://investor.fm/sign-up/

📚 Vitaliy’s books: Soul in the Game – https://amzn.to/43CF73v The Little Book of Sideways Markets – https://amzn.to/3QWTlqZ Active Value Investing – https://amzn.to/3u8zn3A

🌐 Follow Vitaliy: X/Twitter – https://x.com/vitaliykLinkedIn – https://www.linkedin.com/in/katsenelson/ Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/vitaliyk/ Website – https://investor.fm/

_________________________________________________________ WHO AM I: Vitaliy Katsenelson is the CEO of Investment Management Associates (IMA) and an award-winning writer. Forbes Magazine called him “The New Benjamin Graham.” His work has appeared in the Financial Times, The Wall Street Journal, Barron’s, Fortune, Institutional Investor, and Foreign Policy. He is the author of three books, including Soul in the Game: The Art of a Meaningful Life. _________________________________________________________ Please read the following important disclosure: https://investor.fm/disclosure/

View IMA’s regulatory filings — including ADV Part 2A & 2B, Form CRS, firm brochure, conflicts of interest disclosures, sample quarterly letters, and privacy policy — at imausa.com.

New to investing?

Explore these valuable guides to get started.

Related Articles

The Values of Value Investing – Ep 307

What are the real values of value investing? It’s not just cheap stocks—it’s quality, growth, and the wisdom to know the difference.

The World’s Best-Prepared Patient – Ep 306

Nobody in this equation is flawless: not doctors, not us, and not even AI. It hallucinates, making up stories like a Hollywood screenwriter. But it also has perfect recall and lacks the myopic vision of human beings. … That’s the model. Not AI instead of your doctor.

The AI Hangover Is Coming. The Pandemic Already Showed Us How It Ends. – Ep 305

We don’t have to go decades back to find an analogy. Just look back a few years, to the pandemic. We all lived through it, most of us in sweatpants. And it offers a near-perfect preview of what is about to happen in AI.

Your Sophist Filter: On CEOs, Cynics, and the Voice in Your Head – Ep 304

A great speaker can bend logic with emotions and exert undue influence on your decision making. The better someone speaks, the more discriminating your Sophist filter needs to be.

Leave a Comment