Why Value Investing Requires Thoughtful Arrogance

You need arrogance as a value investor, but it can also be your downfall. So how do you master the psychological side of value investing?

Why Value Investing Requires Thoughtful Arrogance

Volatility can be both a feature and a bug of investing. Value investors attempt to treat it as a feature. We try to take advantage of the exuberance of the upswing and the pessimism of the downswing. I use the words attempt and try because though this approach sounds great in theory, reality proves to be a lot more challenging. This gap between theory and practice is created because volatility doesn’t waltz in a vacuum.

Upswings are accompanied by optimism and positive news , or at least the positive spin the crowd puts on the news – this  pushes a stock up. Downswings don’t happen in a vacuum, either; they are accompanied and usually driven by negative news, which results in Mr. Market marking down the value of your initial investment. Fear sets in. What if Mr. Market is right? What if this new news and the army of commentators on CNBC are right? 

As the great American philosopher Mike Tyson said, “Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth.” Theory gives you the game plan (buy more when the stock is down), but then the market punches you in the mouth. 

Our ultimate goal is to narrow the gap between theory and practice and take advantage of volatility. We do this through thoughtful arrogance

Let me explain.

Investing is an act of arrogance. You are basically saying, “I am right and the person on the other side of the transaction, who is buying a stock from me or selling it to me, is wrong.” Value investing takes that arrogance to an even greater extreme, as you are often buying unloved, if not hated, stocks. 

However, arrogance comes in different forms. Plain vanilla arrogance is very dangerous in investing. Softbank CEO Masayoshi Son built Softbank out of nothing. He is one of the richest people in Japan, he is a visionary, and he has had one of the best multidecade investment track records. (I wrote about him when we bought Softbank a long time ago.) 

However, today his Vision Funds are at the tip of the spear of dotcom 2.0 as it shatters against the rock-hard wall of economic reality, losing his investors tens of billions of dollars this year. Mr. Son is solely responsible for it. He recently admitted, “When we were turning out big profits, I become somewhat delirious.” Success went to his head. He started thinking that he had the Midas touch. This is why temperament is so important in investing: We are our own biggest enemy.

And then there is thoughtful arrogance. 

This arrogance requires amnesia of your past successes and failures; it is earned with your current sweat, through thorough research. Your research leads you to conclusions that often disagree but sometimes agree with the prevailing trends in the market. Arrogance – belief in your process and research – allows you to follow through on your conclusions, even if the market scorns them. 

This is how we try to close the gap between theory and practice created by volatility. We continuously build and update our financial models, talk to companies and their competitors and to industry insiders, do a lot of reading, and debate companies with our peers. We have to keep earning the right to be thoughtfully arrogant through our hard work. When time passes, facts change, and new information comes out, we have to have the flexibility to change our minds. (I did this with Softbank when we sold it a few years ago.)

When you are making thoughtfully arrogant decisions, you are ignoring both what the crowd thinks and, just as important, your past successes. You are arrogant (I am paraphrasing Seneca here) because through your research you have discovered the truth (what the company is worth) before time did. 

For example, our Uber investment required a lot of thoughtful arrogance. We endeavor to practice it daily, in every investment decision made.

I plead with you again: Earn thoughtful arrogance through your own sweat and research. It cannot be acquired through reading my articles. I am sharing this with you not to provide you with fish but to teach you how to fish.

Hidden Forces

One last thing. I was interviewed by the brilliant Demetri Kofinas on his Hidden Forces podcast. It is one of the very few podcasts I listen to every week. Along with discussing Soul in the Game, the economy, and the markets, I shared the story of how I got General McChrystal and others to endorse my book. You can listen to the interview here.


Key takeaways

  • Value investing requires a form of thoughtful arrogance, where investors believe in their research and process even when the market disagrees.
  • In value investing, volatility can be both a feature and a bug, with the challenge being to narrow the gap between theory (buying when stocks are down) and practice (overcoming fear during downturns).
  • Value investing often involves buying unloved or hated stocks, which requires a higher degree of arrogance than typical investing, but this arrogance must be thoughtful and earned through thorough research.
  • Successful value investing requires continuous work to maintain thoughtful arrogance, including updating financial models, talking to companies and competitors, and being willing to change one’s mind when facts change.
  • The practice of value investing demands that investors ignore both the crowd’s opinion and their own past successes, focusing instead on their current research and analysis to make investment decisions.

Please read the following important disclosure here.

Related Articles

The Impact of Higher Interest Rates on the Economy - AI Edition

The Impact of Higher Interest Rates on the Economy – AI Edition

I asked AI to educate and entertain my readers with a radio show-style dialogue based on my essay - The Impact of Higher Interest Rates on the Economy.
Navigating Market Cycles From Bulls to Nvidia – AI Edition

Navigating Market Cycles: From Bulls to Nvidia – AI Edition

I asked AI to transform my essays into a radio show-style conversation. In this episode, topic is stock market math, sideways markets, the role of P/E in market cycles, impact of interest rates on P/E, economic analysis, Magnificent Seven stocks, NVIDIA, and a lot more.
Managing a Million What Would I Do Differently

Managing a Million: What Would I Do Differently?

Warren Buffett has stated multiple times that if he could manage a very small amount of money today, he would be able to return more than 50% per year to shareholders. If you managed a million dollars of only your own money, would you do it differently? 
Choosing an Investment Manager Beyond Warren and Charlie

Choosing an Investment Manager: Beyond Warren and Charlie

If you were obliged to invest all your investable assets with one person and you couldn’t choose Warren or Charlie, whom would you pick?

2 thoughts on “Why Value Investing Requires Thoughtful Arrogance”

  1. Hey,
    I got some hint about investing
    while reading this article.
    I like the way you exposed the
    facts. As christian somehow the
    word investor is not my cup of T
    however faith is the highest way
    of investing.
    Thank you for the insights!

    Reply
  2. While these behavioral patterns suggest widespread irrationality among investors, it’s important to note that these deviations from rational behavior are not random. Instead, they tend to be systematic and predictable, which is why they can have significant impacts on market prices and investor returns.

    The field of behavioral finance continues to evolve, challenging traditional financial theories and providing new perspectives on market behavior. It emphasizes the importance of understanding psychological factors in financial decision-making, both for individual investors and for those studying market dynamics.

    Reply

Leave a Comment